TurtleDock
ExamEdge · Free tool

What a guess is actually worth

With four options and a quarter-mark penalty, a blind guess has an expected value of zero. Eliminating one option makes it positive; guessing on questions where you have eliminated nothing but feel confident is where candidates lose marks without realising.

The arithmetic assumes your elimination is genuine. Feeling confident is not the same as having eliminated an option, and the difference is what the calculator makes visible.

Every candidate has heard that you should guess if you can eliminate two options. Almost none have worked out what their own guessing is actually costing them across a full paper, which is a number they can measure.

Blind guess, 4 options
Expected value zero at −0.25
One eliminated
Positive, and worth taking
The trap
Confidence without elimination
Measurable
From your own attempt history
01

The arithmetic, and where intuition fails

Four options, +4 for correct, −1 for wrong.

SituationChance correctExpected valueGuess?
No elimination25%(0.25×4) − (0.75×1) = +0.25Marginal
One eliminated33%(0.33×4) − (0.67×1) = +0.65Yes
Two eliminated50%(0.5×4) − (0.5×1) = +1.50Clearly
Feels right, nothing eliminatedOften below 25%Frequently negativeNo
Illustrative at a +4/−1 scheme. The last row is the one that costs candidates marks.
02

Why the last row is the expensive one

When a distractor is well written, the option that feels right to a candidate who has misunderstood the concept is the one designed to attract exactly that misunderstanding. In those cases the candidate performs worse than chance.

Measuring your own accuracy on questions you guessed — which the calculator does from your attempt history — often shows it sitting below the random baseline. That is worth knowing before an exam rather than after.

FAQ

Questions people ask

Phrased the way they arrive, answered so each one stands on its own.

Should I guess if I can eliminate one option?

On a four-option paper with a quarter-mark penalty, yes — expected value turns clearly positive. The important qualifier is that the elimination has to be genuine rather than a feeling.

Is guessing always worth it with negative marking?

No. Blind guessing is roughly break-even, and guessing where you feel confident without having eliminated anything is often worse than random, because good distractors attract specific misunderstandings.

How do I know my own guessing accuracy?

The calculator computes it from questions you marked as guesses in your attempt history. Most candidates find it lower than they expected.

Related

Read next

Provenance

Who checked this, and against what

Accountability

Checked by the Product desk on 1 September 2026. Corrections go in the page, dated, rather than quietly.

No call required

Tell us your enrolment, we will tell you the number.

Pricing is on the page, in the open, with the counting rule written next to it. Nobody has to book a call to find out what it costs.

See pricing

Bring your own structure. We configure it live on the call.

Forty minutes with an implementation engineer — your classes, your fee heads, your grading scheme, entered as we go. No slides, no sample school.